Skip to content

iPad and Kindle users can’t borrow from e-book libraries

You might find this NPR segment interesting:

iPad and Kindle users can’t borrow from e-book libraries

“Some libraries have e-libraries, so you can browse and borrow any time you’d like. But the top e-readers — Amazon’s Kindle and Apple’s iPad — won’t let you read borrowed e-books, and it doesn’t seem like they’re going to be more library-friendly any time soon.”


“Kai Ryssdal: For all that die-hard bibliophiles say they will never ever give up their actual printed books, they may be fighting a losing battle. E-book sales are up 118 percent this year over last. The number comes from to the Association of American Publishers. You don’t have to buy your e-books though. Public libraries will let you borrow them for nothing. Not without some fine print though.

Gigi Douban reports from Birmingham, Ala.

Gigi Douban: The circulation desk at the downtown branch of the Birmingham Public Library is humming with activity. And long after the library closes for the day, dozens of users will continue to check out books — from home.

The county’s libraries last month launched an e-book collection. Users check e-books out for a couple of weeks by downloading onto a computer or an e-reader. Pat Ryan is director of the county library system.

Pat Ryan: And there are no late fees, no trip to the library, the book expires after the date.

But there’s a hitch. Library e-books don’t work with two of the biggest e-readers — the Amazon Kindle and Apple’s iPad. Analysts put Amazon’s share of the e-book business as high as 90 percent. And giving away free downloads at the library would cut into that share.

Ryan: We’ve had a lot of requests for the Amazon, does it work on the Kindle, and we would love for it to, but they don’t allow anything but the books that they sell for their e-reader.

So that leaves the Kobo and the Nook and other less popular e-readers. As for Apple and Amazon, they’re not in any hurry to jump on board with libraries. A library usually buys just one copy of an e-book, maybe two if it’s a bestseller. Then thousands of people borrow that same copy.

Travis Bryant: It’s real easy to lose control of your product.

That’s Travis Bryant. He’s director of digital products for Keen Communications, which publishes travel and business books.

Digital piracy is a real concern among publishers. In one instance, Bryant’s company found 700 illegal copies of a single book online. And Bryant says book sellers don’t want to mess with a business model that works for them.

Bryant: I think that’s more the case with Amazon, Apple, is that we’re succeeding on our own. If we introduce a third party, an open door, not so much the fear of losing control, but just introducing those variables would not be good to our business model.

Amazon confirmed that library books can’t be downloaded onto the Kindle, but declined to be interviewed for this story. A spokesman for Apple said the only way library books would work on iPads and iPhones is through an app. Right now, there isn’t one available.

Still, many publishers, including Bryant, say having their books on as many virtual shelves as possible — including a library’s — outweighs any potential risk.

Bryant: It’s portable and that’s the big thing, you’re meeting the consumer where they are. And that’s very appealing to publishers, bookstores, libraries.

For their part, libraries seem willing to work with booksellers. After all, the digital age is about immediacy. So if you’re 27th on the waiting list for “The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo,” the library plans to add a “Buy it Now” button.

In Birmingham, I’m Gigi Douban for Marketplace.”

We might love the diversity of providing e-books through libraries but we are currently at the mercy of two major companies (Apple and Amazon) that use their market power to limit access to their devices.

Can anyone imagine a world where we would introduce new innovations like televisions or telephones and allow for there to be poor interoperability between the devices? Or where a dominant supplier could use their device to control access to information, reading, books and the like?

We appear to be in that world now. Libraries and educational institutions need interoperabilty and seamlessness to meet their mandates to educate and inform the generations and citizenry. Doesn’t that trump the rights of a single company an day? When will this environment emerge?


Posted on: October 17, 2010, 4:34 pm Category: Uncategorized

One Response

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. I suggest we all put prominent notes on our sites, FB pages and twitter feeds gently reminding users that “With holiday season approaching, please keep in mind that Kindles and iPads do not work with the library’s ebook collection. [….and then add a link to your vendor’s list of supported devices].

    It may keep a few of our patrons from making purchases they’ll regret (we’ll still have disappointed users in January, but we can at least say we had the note on our site in October!).